Holders of mainland China-issued UnionPay bank cards that wish to use them at Macau automated teller machines (ATMs) will soon have to present their identity card and pass a facial recognition scan to be able to withdraw cash. The news was announced on Monday by the Macau government in a press release.
The new technology will cover “all ATM machines in Macau, including those inside casinos and neighbouring areas,” the document stated.
The policy was announced hours before the expected arrival in Macau of the chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress, Zhang Dejiang. Mr Zhang, the third-highest ranking member in the central government of the People’s Republic of China, is due to be in Macau from Monday to Wednesday. According to investment analyst Grant Govertsen from Union Gaming Securities Asia Ltd, the visit is likely put “a slight damper” on VIP gaming trends in Macau. High-roller play has been accelerating in Macau in year-on-year terms in recent months, say several analysts covering the gaming sector.
Monday’s Macau government release said the new measure on UnionPay ATM machines was aimed at improving the “know your customer” protocols (KYC) of Macau’s financial system. Such protocols aim to strengthen bank and anti-money laundering regulations by ensuring businesses can properly identify and verify the identity of customers.
The Macau government said the new ATM machines with face recognition and identity card-reading technology would be gradually introduced into the market. It did not provide a deadline for all current machines to be replaced by new ones.
“The holders of UnionPay bank cards issued in mainland China that want to withdraw cash from ATM machines bearing the ‘KYC ATM’ logo will have to present their mainland China resident identity card and their identity will have to be verified via facial recognition performed by the ATM,” the Macau government release said.
The document said only people using UnionPay bank cards issued in mainland China would have to undergo the identity recognition procedures. Users of all non-mainland China-issued UnionPay bank cards – or of non-mainland China-issued cards from other providers – would be exempt from such verification procedures.
A Friday news report by Hong Kong-based newspaper the South China Morning Post, claimed – citing a source it did not name – that average aggregate monthly ATM withdrawals in Macau were approximately HKD10 billion (US$1.29 billion).
No big impact expected: JP Morgan
Commenting on the new measure, brokerage JP Morgan Securities (Asia Pacific) Ltd said: “We do not expect the actual impact on [gaming] demand to be very meaningful, as there still are many other ‘channels’ – at least for now – that can help players/junkets to get cash in Macau, via pawnshops for example. That said, we can’t rule out any potential impact on ‘player psychology’, as some players/junkets may feel reluctant to use ATM cards given increased identity checks, so any progress in this area warrants close monitoring in our view.”
The institution’s analysts DS Kim and Sean Zhuang also noted that “it remains to be seen if actual implementation will be smooth given practical (e.g., facial recognition system) and legal (e.g., privacy issues) challenges.”
Brokerage Sanford C. Bernstein Ltd said in a Monday note that “currently in Macau, numerous individuals (exact number is difficult to determine) utilise multiple ATM cards purchased/procured in [mainland] China that are tied to other individuals’ bank accounts.” It stated that the goal of such activity was to circumvent existing daily limits on withdrawals per bank card in Macau.
“Over time though, stronger anti-money laundering and know-your-customer procedures will likely create headwinds for junket activity and certain premium mass liquidity,” said analysts Vitaly Umansky, Zhen Gong and Yang Xie. They added: “The news out of Macau may create downward pressure on the [casino] stocks as investors again realise that Macau risks are largely tied to policy, and the power of the government to limit growth has not been diminished.”
According to the results of a proprietary survey of 1,900 mainland China residents by brokerage Sanford Bernstein, published in January, many casino customers – particularly at the premium end – rely on cash withdrawals from bank accounts held in Macau or Hong Kong, and transactions via UnionPay bank cards, to fund their gambling.
When gambling respondents were asked about their preparations regarding cash to spend at casinos, bringing in cash and using UnionPay-enabled ATMs were the most frequently used methods, with, respectively, 49 percent and 46 percent of self-identified gambling trippers to Macau mentioning these methods. More than 20 percent of such trippers claimed to have access to either Hong Kong or Macau bank accounts, while pawnshops were utilised by nearly 20 percent of such respondents.
“We are fairly confident that capital flight through Macau will remain an issue for Beijing,” analysts Carlo Santarelli and Danny Valoy from Deutsche Bank Securities Inc said in a Monday note commenting on the new policy regarding ATM cash withdrawals. They added: “We also believe the topic to be a gating issue for certain investors who believe the tea leaves speak to a far broader crackdown at some point. Accordingly, and given the history of [casino] stocks, we believe the group is likely to come under pressure in the near term, though we’d be hard pressed to believe there will be any impact to near-term gross gaming revenue.”
Last year, shops in Macau began introducing China UnionPay bank card payment terminals that require holders of China-issued cards to submit an identity document for scanning before their purchase can be confirmed. A number of gaming industry analysts have previously noted that a purchase in Macau made via a UnionPay card – followed rapidly by a return of the goods in exchange for a cash refund – is one of the common ways for some casino gamblers from mainland China to circumvent the country’s strict currency-export controls. Mainland visitors are only allowed to take a daily limit of RMB20,000 (US$3,109) out of China in cash.
Last December, the Monetary Authority of Macao had set a limit of MOP5,000 (US$626) or HKD5,000 per transaction for withdrawals in the city’s ATMs using bank cards issued by mainland China banks. The daily withdrawal limit with the use of such cards remained at CNY10,000 (US$1,447), or at an annual withdrawal limit of CNY100,000.
Macau authorities are currently reviewing two 2006 laws dealing with, respectively, anti-money laundering and combatting the financing of terrorism. The proposed changes are due for a final reading in the city’s Legislative Assembly on Thursday – and likely to be approved, according to legislators involved in the process.
Brokerage Daiwa Securities Group Inc said in a November note from analysts Jamie Soo, Adrian Chan and Jennifer Wu, that in explaining the proposed bill, the government cited “ensuring safety of economic systems in order to attract local and foreign investments, as well as improving the legal framework to comply with the Financial Action Task Force’s 40 new recommendations and to rectify shortcomings identified during the assessment of Macau by the Asia/Pacific Group on Money Laundering.”
Oct 01, 2020Casino gross gaming revenue (GGR) in Macau fell by 90.0 percent year-on-year in September, to MOP2.21 billion (US$277 million), according to data from the city’s Gaming Inspection and Coordination...
Sep 30, 2020
”Everyone’s expectation is to do a percentage of the past year’s [casino revenue in Macau during China’s National Day Golden Week holiday]. No one is expecting to have an immediate rebound"
Vice chairman and chief operating officer of casino operator Wynn Macau Ltd