Investors are unlikely to get clarity any time soon regarding what will happen when the gaming permits of Macau’s six current casino operators expire on various dates between 2020 and 2022.
That is the message in several notes from investment analysts. The memos were issued following Monday comments on the licensing issue made by Lionel Leong Vai Tac, the city’s Secretary for Economy and Finance.
Mr Leong reportedly said the Macau government would analyse various options – including the possibility of legal amendment to existing terms and conditions – regarding any extension of gaming rights for Macau’s current gaming concessions and sub-concessions. Those current permits can be extended in increments of time to a maximum of five years from their original expiry date. After that, a new concession process must take place, involving a new public tender, according to a Macau gaming law expert recently interviewed by GGRAsia.
“Uncertainty… will continue to leave investors with questions,” said a Tuesday note from brokerage Sanford C. Bernstein Ltd.
Commenting on what might happen in relation to any bid process occurring once extension options on the current concessions are exhausted, Sanford Bernstein analysts Vitaly Umansky, Zhen Gong and Yang Xie wrote: “The government will most certainly run some form of an RFP [request for proposal] process with criteria that will make existing concessionaires the evident winners of new concessions (effectively renewals), but likely under new terms, with a potential for economic costs.”
The brokerage cited the land concessions issued by the government to the current gaming operators as supporting evidence for its view that the current six operators would be allowed to remain in the market. In many cases the expiry date of a land concession falls later than the gaming concession attached to it.
“The real estate built upon the land is tied to the land concessions (not the gaming concessions) – except for the actual casino footprint and gaming equipment which fall under the gaming concessions. In the event that an existing concessionaire fails to be effectively renewed [sic], the Macau government can only take possession of the casino areas and equipment (not the remaining assets). Unless the original concessionaire is willing to cooperate and settle for only non-gaming incomes, it would be virtually impossible for the government and a new entrant to operate in the existing properties,” said Sanford Bernstein.
A Monday note from Union Gaming Securities Asia Ltd analyst Grant Govertsen stated: “We don’t expect to hear much more about the nuts and bolts of the licensing process this year or even next. Keep in mind that the licence expirations will occur under the next government’s watch and we would therefore expect the next government to have an outsized say on the licensing process.”
The expiry dates for the current gaming permissions fall beyond the end of the current five-year term of Macau’s Chief Executive, Fernando Chui Sai On, who first took office on December 20, 2009. Mr Chui is barred by law from running for a third consecutive term as Chief Executive.
Relevant Macau law says that any extension to the current concessions and sub-concessions could be accompanied by a change in terms and conditions. If the current concession holders were subsequently to bid for new concessions and be successful, the terms of such new concessions could also be different from the existing ones.
Sanford Bernstein said one scenario for new terms and conditions post 2020 and 2022 – a scenario it thought most likely to occur – was for “higher taxes” and possibly “fees up front or payable over time”.
“A higher tax on mass [play] could be imposed, which would not necessarily have an impact on GGR [gross gaming revenue] generation (and such a bifurcated tax rate already exists in some other jurisdictions around Asia),” noted the brokerage.
Macau operators currently have an effective 39 percent rate of tax on GGR, with the exception of SJM Holdings Ltd, which pays 38 percent, and in return provides dredging services for local waterways.
Other tools available to the government in the future could be an end to exemption from corporate tax on gaming derived business, “resulting in a higher tax burden,” stated Sanford Bernstein.
Future concessionaires might also “be required to invest capital in more non-gaming developments,” added the institution.
Apr 24, 2018April gross gaming revenue (GGR) in the Macau market is heading for year-on-year growth of between 20 percent and 21 percent, but “could surprise on the upside,” said a Monday note from brokerage...
Apr 24, 2018
Jan 04, 2018BMM Testlabs “ticks all the boxes” with regard to its...
Dec 08, 2017The regulated casino industry is well versed in dealing...
Oct 23, 2017The presence of some of the leading cloud computing...
Jul 11, 2017The Tokyo local election setback for Japan’s governing...
Jul 06, 2017A multibillion U.S. dollar casino project on Vietnam’s...
"Aristocrat’s diversified mobile game portfolio approach has the potential to manage risk and monetise better"
Donald Carducci, Shaun Cousins and Shalin Doshi
Analysts at banking group JP Morgan