Brokerage Daiwa Securities Group Inc says market expectations “remain overly optimistic” regarding the impact on Macau’s casino industry of the openings of Wynn Palace and Parisian Macao.
A Wednesday note from Hong Kong-based analysts Jamie Soo and Adrian Chan reiterated the firm’s ‘sell’ advice on shares of Wynn Macau Ltd, the promoter of Wynn Palace, and downgraded Sands China Ltd, promoter of the Parisian Macao, to ‘sell’, from ‘underperform’.
Wynn Macau is opening in less than a week – on August 22 – the US$4.2-billion casino resort Wynn Palace (pictured), located in Macau’s Cotai district. It will become the second property operated by the firm in the city, joining sister property Wynn Macau, a casino hotel located on the Macau peninsula.
Sands China is scheduled to open on September 13 the Parisian Macao casino resort. The property will be the firm’s fourth on Cotai and the fifth overall in Macau.
“We believe the street’s expectations remain overly optimistic when it comes to: the ability of new properties to grow the overall market; the ability of the operators to capture a disproportionate share of the market from their new openings; and the operators collective ability to defend their market share when competitors open new properties,” Mr Soo and Mr Chan wrote on their Wednesday note.
They added: “Our findings suggest that the street remains too bullish on Macau’s overall fundamentals, and particularly for those operators with looming new property openings.”
Japanese brokerage Nomura made a similar assessment in a note issued on Monday. It noted investor expectations could be overblown regarding the ability of the soon-to-launch Wynn Palace and Parisian Macao casino resorts to expand market-wide demand for Macau casino gambling.
Nomura had said in a note in July that any recovery in the Macau gambling market was likely to be of the “slow grind” sort experienced by Las Vegas following the global financial crisis – and driven by the mass-market – rather than the sort of rocketing growth Macau saw in VIP gambling in the years after that same crisis.
Some investment analysts have hinted that August could be the first month of casino gross gaming revenue (GGR) increase in year-on-year terms for the Macau market since May 2014. Macau’s casino GGR for July fell by 4.5 percent year-on-year, according to official data. It was the 26th straight month of GGR retreat, measured in year-on-year terms.
Daiwa has forecast GGR in Macau will decline by 10 percent year-on-year in full year 2016.
No Wynn win
The brokerage’s Mr Soo and Mr Chan raised several question marks in their Wednesday note regarding the performance of the upcoming Wynn Palace.
They stated: “The market remains upbeat on the idea that the ‘unique’ and ‘differentiated’ products offered by Wynn Palace will be game changers that drum up new demand and mark an inflection point for industry GGR growth. To us, these expectations for Wynn look stretched in the context of our analysis of the incremental new capacities introduced since 2010 and the consequent GGR growth and market-share shifts.”
The Daiwa analysts stated that “there is no conclusive evidence over Wynn Macau’s 10-year track record in Macau that shows the success of its properties in taking market share or driving incremental demand in Macau. Indeed, Wynn has been steadily losing market share since Wynn Macau opened in 2006. At its peak, Wynn Macau accounted for more than 17 percent of Macau’s total GGR. Today it accounts for around 10 percent, or around half of the figure eight years ago.”
According to analysis by Daiwa of historical data, “the ability of new gaming/hotel room capacities to drive incremental GGR market share appears to be diminishing.” The brokerage noted that Phase 2 of Galaxy Macau – a property operated by Galaxy Entertainment Group Ltd – and Studio City – majority owned by Melco Crown Entertainment Ltd – “had far less success than previous casino openings in capturing incremental GGR market share, given the increasingly competitive market and larger operating base in Macau today.”
Both Phase 2 of Galaxy Macau and Studio City opened last year.
Analysts Mr Soo and Mr Chan added: “Since the openings of these Cotai 2.0 properties, they have captured an additional 1.4 percentage points GGR market share individually while adding to the market some 4 percent to 6 percent of new capacity.”
The Daiwa analysts also noted that, in recent years, the biggest market share losers regarding the launch of new properties had been the respective operators of those new casinos. “In our view, the consensus forecasts also suggest that the street still underestimates the significant impact of the operators’ cannibalisation of their own properties on the back of the new property openings,” they stated.
The chairman and chief executive of Wynn Macau, Steve Wynn, said on Wednesday he had no forecast for when Wynn Palace might reach break-even, or about the property’s return on investment. Mr Wynn was speaking at a press conference on Wednesday in Macau to preview the launch of Wynn Palace.
Throughout the media event, Mr Wynn highlighted several times that Wynn Palace aimed to cover all market segments, including luxury and the mass market.
“This place was built for everybody,” he told reporters. “The difference between the least expensive room here and the least expensive room in the city is very tinny.”
A hotel price survey by Morgan Stanley analysts Praveen Choudhary and Alex Poon showed otherwise. The results of the survey – disclosed in a Wednesday note – showed Wynn Palace had the third highest average hotel room rates in Macau, only behind the Ritz-Carlton and Banyan Tree, two hotel brands at Galaxy Entertainment Group Ltd’s Cotai flagship Galaxy Macau.
The ranking was based on Macau hotel rates between September 15 and September 25, and was conducted on August 16. Results featured average prices – before tax – for the lowest tier of rooms in each of the properties surveyed.
A night at Wynn Palace cost on average HKD2,430 (US$313). In comparison, Parisian Macao rooms were priced at around HKD1,611. To stay at Studio City, guests would have to fork out on average HKD1,450 per night, according to Morgan Stanley.
Aug 01, 2017Sponsored content Aristocrat Leisure Ltd strives to lead the gaming industry in creating combinations of innovative cabinets and games that really entertain. Its game and cabinet creations are designed to help operators cater to all types of players and gaming floor segments. “Our global teams of...
Sep 20, 2017The casino at Legend Palace, a Macau waterfront resort (pictured), restarted operations on Wednesday after being shuttered for nearly four weeks due to flooding linked to Typhoon Hato, which struck...
Sep 20, 2017
Aug 11, 2017Macau’s traditional gaming zone on downtown peninsula...
Jun 27, 2017Management at two major casino venues in the Philippine...
Nov 23, 2016Hong Kong-listed casino equipment supplier Paradise...
Oct 27, 2016As Studio City – the US$3.2-billion, 2015 addition to...
May 26, 2016Macau’s pacapio Chinese lottery game will celebrate its...
”Until now, we have not received any [casino] application for [Royal Dragon]"
Paulo Martins Chan
Director of Macau’s casino regulator Gaming Inspection and Coordination Bureau