The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) said on Thursday it was concerned about harm to the public interest if a Hong Kong-based developer were allowed to take over a casino in Cairns, Queensland, while at the same time building a 750-table casino resort on the outskirts of the city.
Aquis Reef Holdings (Aus) Pty Ltd wants to acquire the Reef Hotel Casino (pictured), a Cairns property currently focused on mass-market customers, in exchange for A$216.86 million (US$203.20 million). At the same time Aquis is seeking approval to build a 7,500-room casino resort costing A$8.15 billion in two phases at nearby Yorkeys Knob.
An entity called Aquis Resort at The Great Barrier Reef Pty Ltd – the proponent of the Aquis resort – is wholly and solely owned by Tony Fung, a Hong Kong resident and “long term investor in Queensland” according to a submission the developer made to the state government in July 2013.
Mr Fung, also known by his Cantonese name Fung Wing Cheung, is a U.S. dollar billionaire and a former chairman of the Hong Kong-based financial services company Sun Hung Kai & Co Ltd, founded in 1969 by Mr Fung’s father, property developer Fung King Hey.
Ambrose So Shu Fai, chief executive of Macau casino developer SJM Holdings Ltd, is an independent non-executive director of Yu Ming Group, a Hong Kong company founded by Mr Fung, according to Yu Ming’s English-language website.
Up to three new casino licences are on offer in Queensland, one of them for Queen’s Wharf in the state capital Brisbane. The state is expected to announce its decision on all bids next year.
The federal competition commission said in a statement on Thursday regarding Aquis’ plans: “The proposed acquisition [of Reef Casino] has the potential to reduce the number of casino owners in Cairns from two to one, removing potential competition between the Reef Casino and the Aquis Resort.”
But the commission added: “Aquis has submitted to the ACCC that if the proposed acquisition [of Reef Casino] did not proceed and if the Aquis Resort was developed, the two casinos would not compete with each other for mass customers in a material way.”
This was because Aquis would be targeting mainly high rollers from overseas including China, said the proposed developer. The current lowest minimum bet on live table games at the Reef Casino is A$2.50 (HK$18.16) according to the commission. The lowest minimum bet on live table games in most Macau casinos currently is HK$500, according to GGRAsia’s observations.
But the commission said the fact Aquis had applied for permission for 1,500 gaming machines as well as 750 tables raised other concerns.
“Even if the final resort as constructed does not include as many tables and machines as this, it will still be around the scale of the largest existing casinos in Australia. The ACCC is considering whether: a) the Aquis Resort would be able to attract enough customers to operate a casino on such a large scale without appealing to all types of mass customers; b) the large number of gaming machines would be necessary if Aquis did not intend to attract lower stake mass customers.”
Even if the commission were minded to recommend that Mr Fung not be allowed to take over Reef Hotel Casino at the same time as seeking to build Aquis Resort, it is not clear whether the decision would be binding on either the state or federal government.
Australia’s central government, formed by the Liberal Party, pledged a “root and branch” review of competition policy as part of its 2013 election campaign.
The review’s draft terms of reference state: “A modern competition policy should provide a framework with the right incentives and enabling provisions that fosters vigorous and healthy competitive processes, allowing Australia to take advantage of the opportunities an increasingly global marketplace provides.”
Queensland’s state government, also formed by the Liberal Party, is currently the nation’s most indebted regional government. According to its 2014-15 budget, it owes A$80 billion, with a A$4 billion annual interest bill.
It is looking to issue casino licences and boost tax revenues from gambling as part of its efforts to balance its books. Australian Securities Exchange Ltd-listed Echo Entertainment Group Ltd already operates the Treasury Casino & Hotel Brisbane, and the Jupiters Hotel & Casino Gold Coast. Echo in January agreed to sell its Jupiters Townsville property to Colonial Leisure Group Pty Ltd for A$70 million.
Another investor called ASF Consortium Pty Ltd, led by an ASX-listed Sino-Australian company called ASF Group, made a bid with the Queensland government in February for a A$7.5 billion casino resort at Broadwater on Queensland’s Gold Coast. The project was shortlisted for consideration in May.
Queensland’s inward investment drive coincides with a period of increasing competition in the Macau gaming industry.
Aug 01, 2017Sponsored content Aristocrat Leisure Ltd strives to lead the gaming industry in creating combinations of innovative cabinets and games that really entertain. Its game and cabinet creations are designed to help operators cater to all types of players and gaming floor segments. “Our global teams of...
Aug 18, 2017The total spending – excluding gaming expenses – of visitors to Macau reached MOP13.75 billion (US$1.71 billion) in the second quarter of 2017, up by 17.5 percent compared to the prior-year...
Aug 18, 2017
Aug 11, 2017Macau’s traditional gaming zone on downtown peninsula...
Jun 27, 2017Management at two major casino venues in the Philippine...
Nov 23, 2016Hong Kong-listed casino equipment supplier Paradise...
Oct 27, 2016As Studio City – the US$3.2-billion, 2015 addition to...
May 26, 2016Macau’s pacapio Chinese lottery game will celebrate its...
”We expect Okada [Manila] to add US$1.2 billion of GGR by 2019 to the overall market, capturing 32 percent market share”
Alex Poon and Praveen Choudhary
Analysts at Morgan Stanley